« Strong ties in SD18: a former aide, Republican activists and Scott Newman's social network | Main | Making lists, naming names: MN Republicans, the Aspen Institute and the Axis of Soros »

Mar 10, 2011

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Phoenix Woman

Actually, the show I was envisioning was Monty Python's Flying Circus.

A favorite bit of theirs involved a knight with a chicken going up to blithering idiots and smacking them with said chicken: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTt-ewgKm5A

I kept waiting for something similar to happen to Mr. G.

Mark Heitkamp

I am always disappointed when someone reports second hand news, which turns out to be either false or deceptive.

The Le Center Leader article you quote failed to attribute Glenn's statement to the source. Glenn was quoting or paraphrasing DFL State Representative Tom Anzelc, District 3A, standing to support HF1, as seen in this video at time marker 4:08:45.
http://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/htv/programa.asp?ls_year=87&session_year=2011&session_number=0&event_id=3253

If you watch DFL Rep Anzelc, you will find that your argument is simply nonsensical.

The floor debate on HF1 begins at 2:01:50. It would be good to see you make a correction to your reporting on this issue.

Bluestem replies:
How unfortunate that you think that an impossible argument like that advanced by Gruenhagen is somehow valid if a DFLer makes it.

But it matters not who argues that had the current permitting been in place in World War II that the war effort would have been compromised.

It sounds scary to think that we might have lost World War II had _______ happened, whatever the _______ might be.

But to use that fear to argue against current regulation ignores the massive mobilization of the economy and creation of bureaucracies--and changing of rules--that went on in order to win the war.

The US Steel/Anzelc/Gruenhagen comparison is silly--a misapplication of a historical analogy to a present circumstance--and your notion that Gruenhagen is somehow validated by repeating an impossible argument is simply an appeal to the authority of Anzelc's person, and not a confirmation of his logic.

Instead, that Gruenhagen chose to repeat something he heard demonstrates that members of both parties can be tempted to employ fearsome but faulty logic shared by corporate representatives.

A point has to stand regardless of who said it, and thus the local paper isn't at fault for failing to attribute the analogy to someone else, given that Gruenhagen agreed with it, and used it to illustrate his own ongoing war against the MPCA and government regulation.

sjs

Mark Heitkamp

Please do not put your words into my quill. I never made the arguement that either side was correct. I was merely asking if, now you know that the DFL made the argument (first), would you ridicule them as well. Since it appears that you are willing to make the logical arguement against the WWII analogy, I submit that you are ridiculing both sides, but have made Glenn out to be the fool, while not holding the DFL to the same ridicule. In my book you owe Minnesota State Legislator Glenn Gruenhagen an apology. Mark

Bluestem replies:

You made no plea in your first comment that I ridicule Anzelc, simply that I correct the record. Your comment was posted.

All readers can see it, and if they see that you ask me to ridicule Anzelc, rather than simply to admit that my objections to the analogy were "nonsensical," then they are far more clairvoyant than I.

As for dictating of what Bluestem's content can be--whether the substance of posts or the comments--bluster all you wish.

Many have tried to do tell me what to write--almost entirely progressives and DFLers, whose esteem, logic and reputations you appear to cherish far more deeply than I do--and they have simply wound up peeping through a keyhole on their knees, as a bard from Hibbing once sang.

Phoenix Woman

Game, set and match to Bluestem!

Sorry about your butthurt, Mr. Heitkamp.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Payment options

My Other Accounts

Important Information

  • All of the statements, opinions, and views expressed on this site by Sally Jo Sorensen are solely her own, save when she attributes them to other sources.

    The opinions, statements, and views of contributing writers are their own.

    Sorensen, editor and proprietor of Bluestem Prairie, serves clients in the business and nonprofit sectors. While progressive in outlook, she does not caucus with any political party.

StatCounter

  • StatCounter

Become a Fan

Bluestem Tweets

    follow me on Twitter
    Blog powered by Typepad