Some folks don't know how to apologize, unless it's about gun regulations. That what we're learning about Republican gubernatorial candidate Scott Jensen.
Readers may recall our posts From the Minnesota Reformer; Jensen: Yes, I was comparing COVID-19 restrictions to Nazism and Scott Jensen awful analogy news digest: public health measures like Kristallnacht, Nazism.
The story continues to have legs.
TCJewfolk's Lonny Goldsmith first broke the story in Watch: Jensen Says Mask Mandates Like Kristallnacht. on Wednesday afternoon, Goldsmith reported in Did Scott Jensen Triple Down On Holocaust Comparisons? You Betcha!:
Scott Jensen’s appearance at Tuesday night’s Republican Jewish Coalition was an opportunity to quell the controversy over the Republican gubernatorial candidate comparing masking requirements to the Kristallnacht and Nazi book burning. Jensen, however, decided to keep the story going.
In audio released Wednesday by Heartland Signal, Jensen said that the mandates placed by Gov. Tim Walz during the height of COVID-19 “has parallels” to the rise of the Nazis.
NEW: MN GOP Gov. nominee Scott Jensen (on Day 3 of blowback from comparing COVID policy to Nazism) says U.S. media complacency is akin to 1930s Germany and claims contact tracing is about "control."
— Heartland Signal (@HeartlandSignal) August 24, 2022
"Minnesota like never before needs to lean into the Jewish tradition," he adds. pic.twitter.com/55CzJ4UlCS
...On Tuesday, in response to the initial blowback, he hosted a Facebook Live video where he defended the comments, saying in part:
“I want to speak to a little bit of a hubbub that’s been in the media lately about whether or not I was insensitive in regards to the Holocaust. I don’t believe I was,” Jensen said. “I was making a comparison between the incremental change that frequently occurs and is oftentimes missed by people living through it at the time. It’s oftentimes incremental change designed by government to effect sweeping societal changes, frequently centering on compliance and control.”
On Tuesday, in response to the initial blowback, he hosted a Facebook Live video where he defended the comments, saying in part:
“I want to speak to a little bit of a hubbub that’s been in the media lately about whether or not I was insensitive in regards to the Holocaust. I don’t believe I was,” Jensen said. “I was making a comparison between the incremental change that frequently occurs and is oftentimes missed by people living through it at the time. It’s oftentimes incremental change designed by government to effect sweeping societal changes, frequently centering on compliance and control.” . . .
Ethan Roberts, the director of governmental affairs for the Jewish Community Relations Council of Minnesota and the Dakotas, had invited Jensen to sit with the JCRC staff to hear why they feel the comparison is misguided.
“Since April of 2020, we have been saying, over and over, to the point where I’m feeling like no one is listening, that these comments are inflammatory and they trivialize the Holocaust,” Roberts said. “They just are wrong; so wrong. I understand he is trying to talk about incrementalism but why can’t Dr. Jensen find some other analogy that doesn’t involve, first, the dehumanization of my people? And the systemic murder and genocide of my people?”
Beth Gendler, the executive director of Jewish Community Action, is the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, and was incredulous at the comparison.
“Policies that are implemented to save lives and keep all of us safe are nothing like the policies in Nazi Germany that forced my grandparents out of their home, separated them from their children, and ultimately murdered them in Auschwitz,” Gendler said. “The false equivalence is not only damaging and wrong it is deeply hurtful, especially coming from someone who is running to represent all Minnesotans.” . . .
Read the whole hot mess at TCJewfolk.
At the Star Tribune, Briana Bierschbach reports in Minnesota GOP governor nominee Scott Jensen triples down on comparing COVID policies to Nazi Germany.
Minnesota Republican candidate for governor Scott Jensen continues to stir controversy over recent comments likening mask mandates to measures in Nazi Germany, defending those remarks twice this week and drawing criticism from Democratic elected officials and some Jewish groups.
The comments, made to an anti-COVID mandate group in April and posted on Twitter this week by online media hub TC Jewfolk, are the latest from the physician and former state senator who rose to prominence in the party over his opposition to lockdown measures meant to slow the spread of the pandemic. But the remarks quickly drew criticism over his comparison of pandemic mandates such as masking to actions taken by Nazi Germany in the 1930s that helped Adolf Hitler rise to power.
"The little things grew into something bigger. Then there was a night called Kristallnacht, the night of the breaking glass," Jensen said at an event with the group Mask Off Minnesota. "Then there was the book burning, and it kept growing and growing, and a guy named Hitler kept growing in power. … In a way, I think that's why you're here today, is you sense that something is happening, and it's growing little by little."
Jensen doubled down on those comments in a video posted to Facebook on Tuesday and again at an event with the Republican Jewish Coalition, according to audio obtained by the DFL Party and provided to the Star Tribune. A reporter for the Star Tribune was told the event was closed to the press.
In the video posted on Facebook Tuesday, Jensen said he doesn't believe he was being insensitive about the Holocaust when he talked about "incremental change designed by government to effect sweeping societal changes."
"I think it's a legitimate comparison," he said, adding, "You don't get to be my thought police person."
Later in the evening, at the Jewish GOP event with other Republican statewide candidates for office, Jensen echoed those comparisons and said Democrats were trying to "demonize" him and distract voters from their party's record on issues such as crime and the economy.
"What's happened over the last two and a half years has parallels to what happened with the 1933 banning of books, banning of Jewish authors, burning of books, Kristallnacht in 1938," he said. "This was a sequence of events that should never have been happening. It should never have been turned away from. It should have been elevated, but the media wasn't there, and we're seeing the same thing in America today."
Some Jewish groups and elected officials have criticized Jensen for the remarks, including Minnesota DFL U.S. Rep. Dean Phillips.
"I believe in our freedom of speech," Phillips tweeted, "but comparing Nazi Kristallnacht, which murdered human beings, to the wearing of masks to reduce COVID transmission, which saved human beings — is repulsive and shameful." . . .
Republican lieutenant governor candidate Matt Birk defended Jensen at an event in Minneapolis on Wednesday, saying voters are more concerned with issues such as crime than comments like Jensen's.
"We know the game. I've been victim of it," said Birk, who has been criticized for past comments on abortion. "Scott's been a victim of it for a long time. You take 10-second sound clips … and it's the age of outrage on Twitter."
Oh. They're the victims here. I seem to remember learning something about this sort of rhetoric back in that "Reflections on Anti-Semitism in American Film" course I took at Hamline back before the world turned nasty,
In an updated report, 'It's a legitimate comparison': MN GOP gubernatorial candidate Scott Jensen defends remarks about COVID, Nazism, KARE-11 reports how this played out in one state senator's closest circle:
Gov. Walz's campaign manager, Nichole Johnson, wrote in a statement from the governor's office that it views Jensen's comments as "outrageous" and "unacceptable."
“Scott Jensen’s decision to double down on his outrageous remarks about the Holocaust are unacceptable for anyone seeking the governor’s office,” she said.
Also on Tuesday, the wife of Minnesota Sen. Jim Abeler (R-Anoka), Barb Abeler, wrote a response to criticism of Jensen in a now-deleted tweet, reading:
"Really????? You still don't get it?? Masks were proven not to work, yet like nazis they mandated them! What a joke! And all the sheep went along without question. Heil Hitler!"
Through the miracle of twitter, Bluestem was able to find a screenshot of the tweet:
The report continues:
On Wednesday, Abeler tweeted again, this time to "apologize" for the "inappropriate tweet."
I want to apologize for my inappropriate tweet and the people it hurt. I want to defend people’s rights & freedoms, but went too far. Too much hurt & division has gone on these past 2 years. Again, I truly apologize for hurting anyone.
— Barbara Abeler (@BarbAbeler) August 24, 2022
Well, that's something. Replies to the tweet question her sincerity.
As some of the related posts below illustrate, the use of these sort of bad analogies in Republican circles didn't start with Jensen.
Related posts:
- Scott Jensen to speak--again--at "vaccine awareness" Global Health Freedom Summit
- Scott Jensen awful analogy news digest: public health measures like Kristallnacht, Nazism
- From the Minnesota Reformer; Jensen: Yes, I was comparing COVID-19 restrictions to Nazism
- Jewish Community Action calls out GOP's Julie Buria for yet another Holocaust-themed meme
- Nazi namecalling: two Southern MN Republicans lose their wits about Warren, insulin critics
- Hagedorn campaign embraces NRCC's anti-semitic anti-Soros ad condemned by Jewish Community Relations Council
- Hagedorn campaign changes tune on control of NRCC anti-Semitic ad, but still a-ok with content
- GOP SOS candidate we scolded for racism, incompetence gets antisemitism added
- MNGOP endorsed secretary of state candidate's election ignorance pairs well with past racism
Photo: Minnesota gubernatorial candidate Scott Jensen speaks as supporters cheer behind him at an Apple Valley rally in May. Bluestem would hope that with his track record of awful analogies, he might be a little less fingerpointy. Photo by Nicole Neri/Minnesota Reformer.
If you appreciate Bluestem Prairie, you can mail contributions (payable to Sally Jo Sorensen, 600 Maple Street, Summit SD 57266) or use the paypal button in the upper right hand corner of this post.
Or you can contribute via this link to paypal; use email [email protected] as recipient.
I'm on Venmo for those who prefer to use this service: @Sally-Sorensen-6
Comments