Update: I recommend readers check out Bluestem's republishing MinnPost: Gettin’ messy under the DFL tent: 16 Minnesota environmental groups call out Governor Walz over ‘polluter capture’ from Tuesday afternoon. Peter Callaghan adds House Environment and Natural Resources Finance and Policy Committee chair, S. St. Paul DFLer Rick Hansen's view of People Not Polluters' recommendations. [end update]
Are Minnesota agencies failing the North Star state's environment? Bluestem believes a number of environmental groups are on to something: "polluter capture." one variety of regulatory capture.
At the Star Tribune, Chloe Johnson and Greg Stanley report in Environmental groups say Minnesota failed to stop polluters, should hold statehouse hearings on enforcement:
From industrial plants to farm country pollution, the MPCA, DNR, MDH and MDA have lapsed in environmental enforcement, a coalition of environmental groups claims.
Nitrates that contaminated rural well water, an iron foundry that fouled the air in a south Minneapolis neighborhood, a potato farm that overused a sensitive aquifer — in all of these cases, a group of environmental organizations claim, the state of Minnesota failed in its duty to protect the environment.
Now, the coalition of 16 groups is urging lawmakers to hold hearings on the state's environmental protections, and make state agency leaders in Gov. Tim Walz's administration answer for several recent episodes. They claim the four state agencies responsible for protecting the environment — the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Department of Natural Resources, Department of Health and Department of Agriculture — have offered too little oversight of the polluters and industries they should be regulating. . .
The groups that have signed on to the campaign include Climate Generation, Clean Up the River Environment (CURE), East Phillips Neighborhood Institute, Friends of the Boundary Waters, Health Professionals for a Healthy Climate, the Izaak Walton League, Minnesota Environmental Justice Table, Minnesota Environmental Partnership, Minnesota Interfaith Power & Light, Minnesota Well Owners Organization, MN350, Pollinator Friendly Alliance, Sierra Club, TakeAction Minnesota, Waadookawaad Amikwag (Those Who Help Beaver), and WaterLegacy. . . .
At the Minnesota Reformer:
Environmental groups call for hearings over MPCA issues
By Madison McVanA coalition of environmental groups is calling for legislative hearings over the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency’s failure to detect and curb pollution in several instances in recent years.
In a press release, the groups accused the agency — as well as the state departments of Health, Agriculture and Natural Resources — of “polluter capture,” meaning the agencies’ decisionmaking has been “captured” by corporate influence.
“We ask legislators to fulfill their constitutional role to ensure the agencies live up to their responsibilities and secure clean water and air for all,” said Steve Morse, a former state senator and the executive director of the Minnesota Environmental Partnership.
Among the groups: Climate Generation, Clean Up the River Environment, Friends of the Boundary Waters, Pollinator Friendly Alliance, Sierra Club North Star Chapter.
The push by environmentalists reveals some Minnesota progressives’ discontent with the administration of second-term DFL Gov. Tim Walz, who has long sought to balance jobs and economic growth with environmental concerns.
In a statement, a spokesperson for Walz said the governor’s office is proud of Minnesota’s agencies: “The state has a strong record of holding polluters accountable and working with the community and the Legislature to ensure health and our natural resources are protected.”
The green coalition pointed to a dozen instances where state regulators delayed or did not take action against a polluting company or industry, or made permitting and regulatory decisions that were favorable to companies.
The EPA found during a surprise inspection that the Smith Foundry in the East Phillips neighborhood of Minneapolis was emitting more particulate matter than allowed by federal regulations. After the EPA found the violations, the Star Tribune reported that MPCA officials appeared to contradict the EPA’s findings, saying the state agency did not have evidence that the foundry was violating state or federal rules.
The EPA settled with the Smith Foundry last week, and the foundry will close its furnace within a year.
“It took a surprise inspection from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to bring to light something we have known for years. We don’t understand why the MPCA has sided with a polluter for so long,” said Joe Vital, organizer with the East Phillips Neighborhood Institute, in a press release.
Environmentalists also cite nitrate pollution in drinking water in southeastern Minnesota, largely attributable to farm runoff; the EPA warned state leaders in November that they were not doing enough to curb the problem.
Federal officials have also withheld grant money from the DNR for logging violations, alleging state officials failed to ensure that timber harvesting on public land was done with wildlife habitat in mind, not private interests.
This Minnesota Reformer article is republished online under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.
Photo: A moose on the loose. US Forest Service via Minnesota Reformer, Feds withhold conservation funding over DNR logging practices by Christopher Ingraham.
Related posts
- Prevention is better than clean-up: split vote sends budget, policy bill out of enviro committee
- Nitrate treatment represents bulk of spending proposed in ag finance, policy bill
- Minnesota House passes environment policy bill
- DNA, inbreeding issues: Rusty patched bumble bees' survival may take more than habitat
- The New Lede: Cancer in the corn belt sparks actions to fight farm chemical contamination
- In amicus brief, five ag groups ask to weigh in on ruling that blocked Daley dairy’s expansion plans
- Will MPCA's Clean Water Council recommend unconstitutional use of Legacy funds for mitigation of nitrate contamination of wells??
- State's southeastern Minnesota drinking water fix: grab donuts, coffee, and lobbyists, oh my
- Agency soup: MPCA, DNR, MDH & Ag release "Preventing fish kills in MN driftless region"
- Minnesota nitrate pollution update: raise fertilizer fees to help pay cost of nitrate pollution
- Land Stewardship Project applauds court’s support of Winona County; launches ‘Story Center Powerline’ initiative for rural residents
- Minnesota district court rules against Winona County dairy expansion; owner will appeal
- Agweek Special Report on Rural Health: 10% of MN private wells pose a health problem
- This is fine: update on MN state agencies' response to EPA letter on karst country nitrates
- Following emergency petition regarding nitrate contamination in SEMN karst region, EPA sees further action needed to protect public health
- On ‘Cancer Road,’ a group of southeastern MN families ask if nitrate exposure is to blame
- Eleven environmental groups petition EPA on nitrate pollution in Southeast Minnesota wate
- Strib scrutinizes MN Department of Ag action on nitrate-related Groundwater Protection Rule
- Nitrates in Southwestern Minnesota water: 'Do not give the water to infants' in Ellsworth
- Commentary from MinnPost: Can the state control nitrates in Minnesota waters?
- Minnesota Department of Health isn’t properly enforcing drinking water law, and kids will suffer
- Packed house at Newburg Township on using local control to protect community, karst
- All citizens are equal, but one thinks he's more equal: massive hog farm shareholder* seeks to prevent August 2 Newburgh Township meeting
- Jean Wagenius: For climate and clean water, state agencies need Walz to lead
If you appreciate Bluestem Prairie, you can mail contributions (payable to Sally Jo Sorensen, 600 Maple Street, Summit SD 57266) or use the paypal button in the upper right hand corner of this post.
Or you can contribute via this link to paypal; use email [email protected] as recipient.
I'm on Venmo for those who prefer to use this service: @Sally-Sorensen-6
Comments