Yet another story chronicling the struggle over ethanol carbon pipelines in the upper Midwest.
At the North Dakota Monitor, Jeff Beach reports an option is available for landowners who feel they were tricked or bullied into signing easement agreements with Summit Carbon Solutions for ethanol carbon pipelines.
PSC staff outlines legal option for landowners in Summit pipeline fight
by Jeff BeachNorth Dakota landowners who feel they were tricked or bullied into signing an easement agreement with Summit Carbon Solutions can appeal to the courts, according to staff for the Public Service Commission.
During a PSC work session Monday on the Summit siting permit, staff discussed the law that says if five or more landowners feel wronged by the negotiating tactics, they can file a complaint in district court.
If the court sides with the landowners, the easement agreements can be thrown out.
During public hearings on Summit’s carbon capture pipeline project, landowners have complained that Summit agents threatened them with court action if they did not voluntarily sign an easement agreement giving Summit the right to put a pipeline through private property.
They also have cited poor communication and sometimes communicating with the wrong family member on easement negotiations.
According to Century Code 49-22.1-14, “If at least five landowners aggrieved by the conduct of a person or persons acting on behalf of the same utility, acquiring easements for a site a relevant facility, alleged use of harassment, misrepresentation, deception, fraud, or other unfair tactics by the person and persons acquiring or attempting to acquire easement and action may be brought to the appropriate District Court.”
“It covers, it seems like, just about everything we’ve been hearing about all along that is supposedly happening,” PSC Chair Randy Christmann said of landowner complaints about Summit. “There’s a process for it.”
The law adds that if the court rules in favor of the landowners, the PSC may revoke or suspend the route permit affecting the landowners who proved that they were wronged.
Victor Shock, director of public utilities for the commission, noted that the commission doesn’t have jurisdiction over easement negotiations. “But that is something that the court could do,” Shock said.
PSC attorney Zack Pelham said the law has been in place since 2017. He said he was unsure if there had been previous versions of the statute.
Iowa-based Summit Carbon Solutions has been pursuing a pipeline route permit in North Dakota since 2022. It seeks to capture carbon emissions from ethanol plants in five states and use the pipeline to bring carbon dioxide to North Dakota for underground storage.
But Summit has faced opposition and legal action from some landowners.
The PSC in 2023 denied Summit a route permit but allowed the company to revise its application and go through a second round of public hearings.
Monday’s work session was a chance for the three-person commission to discuss the law covering negotiation tactics and other legal matters related to the pipeline as the PSC weighs a decision on the permit.
The commission directed its staff to ask for more detailed information on Summit’s insurance policies.
Another PSC work session on the pipeline was tentatively set for 9:30 a.m. Sept. 16, in the Brynhild Haugland Room at the Capitol. Christmann said in an interview last week he anticipates multiple work sessions on the project before the PSC will be prepared to vote on the permit.
This North Dakota Monitor article is republished online under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.
Photo: Members of the public review maps on display April 22, 2024, that show the Summit Carbon Solutions pipeline route ahead of a Public Service Commission meeting in Mandan. (Kyle Martin/For the North Dakota Monitor).
Related posts
- Livestreaming today at 1:30, ND regulators to hold work session to discuss Summit pipeline
- Summit Carbon Solutions pipelines won’t capture all carbon emitted by ethanol plants
- Breaking news: Iowa Utilities Commission issues ethanol carbon pipeline permit for Summit Carbon Solutions
- Ethanol carbon news digest: Summit Carbon pipeline in MN, Iowa & North Dakota media
- South Dakota Supreme Court ruling complicates Summit Carbon Solution’s push for land
- Public can comment on Otter Tail – Wilkin Co section of ethanol carbon pipeline until Sept. 11
- Summit Carbon Solutions CEO asks for prayer, while MN PUC wants public comment on FEIS of Otter Tail – Wilkin portion of CO2 Pipeline
- More carbon pipeline news: Summit jumpstarts pipeline efforts with purchase of old land easement agreements in Iowa
- IA Rep. Miller-Meeks says carbon pipelines will help Iowa ethanol industry stay competitive
- VIDEO: Carbon capture in Minnesota: public lands, fast money, and pipe dreams
- Summit pipeline segment enters final permitting stages in Minnesota; CURE raises objections
- Referred pipeline law puts Summit Carbon Solution's permit quest in limbo
- Carbon capture news from elsewhere: New Illinois law lays out safety requirements for future carbon sequestration projects
- Broad array of groups object to Summit pipeline permit approval by Iowa Utilities Commission
- Iowa ethanol carbon pipeline opponents poised for Summit Carbon Solutions permit challenges
- Breaking crowded South Dakota ballot news: carbon pipeline law referendum validated
- Sustainable jet fuel company Gevo contributes $167K in defense of carbon pipeline law
- South Dakota Property Rights and Local Control Alliance turns in petitions to SD Secretary of State to force a vote on carbon pipeline policy
- News digest: District 1, the edge of the primary election political earthquake in South Dakota
- South Dakota District 1 GOP House primary news round-up: carbon pipeline politics major issue
- New Midwest battles brew over CO2 pipelines
- Company behind proposed Lake Preston jet fuel plant buoyed by federal carbon credit ruling
- Ethanol carbon pipeline news digest: Gevo aviation fuel needs Summit Carbon Solutions and more!
- ND GOP resolution against CCS pipelines decries "false premise of looming climate apocalypse
- Summit Carbon Solutions says ethanol carbon pipeline system won’t be operational until 2026
- Some Iowa landowners were confused by Summit Carbon Solution eminent domain process
- Navigator CO2 pulls its ethanol carbon pipeline permit application in Illinois
- Ethanol carbon pipeline news digest: Gevo aviation fuel needs Summit Carbon Solutions and more!
If you appreciate Bluestem Prairie, you can mail contributions (payable to Sally Jo Sorensen, 600 Maple Street, Summit SD 57266) or use the paypal button in the upper right hand corner of this post.
Or you can contribute via this link to paypal; use email [email protected] as recipient.
I'm on Venmo for those who prefer to use this service: @Sally-Sorensen-6
Comments