Some South Dakota lawmakers upset after Noem awards millions to project they refused to pay for

We've been publishing news of project funded by the South Dakota  Future Fund, which is controlled by Governor Noem. It hasn't been pretty. 

Now the South Searchlight has caught another wrinkle in the use of the fund, one that's making South Dakota lawmakers on both side of the partisan divide unhappy.

Some lawmakers upset after Noem awards millions to project they refused to pay for
by Joshua Haiar

Governor using money from state’s Future Fund to help build shooting range

While legislators were passing a law in March requiring more information from Republican Gov. Kristi Noem about a fund she controls, Noem was awarding $13.5 million from the fund to a project legislators had declined to financially support.

Some legislators didn’t find out about the spending until this week, when South Dakota Searchlight learned about it and told them.

The money will go toward the construction of a $20 million, state-owned shooting range in a rural area north of Rapid City. The Department of Game, Fish and Parks is also counting on private fundraising to help the project.

Game, Fish and Parks spokesman Nick Harrington said in a statement that the shooting range will “attract new visitors to the state and increase opportunities for firearms-related industries to expand in South Dakota.”

The $13.5 million awarded by Noem is from the Future Fund, which is supported by a tax on employers and spent at the discretion of the governor.

Legislators have denied requests to fund the shooting range with money from the state budget. State Sen. Reynold Nesiba, D-Sioux Falls, said Noem’s decision “demonstrates the need for greater transparency and legislative oversight of the Future Fund.” He called the shooting range a “pet project” for Noem that “excites few outside her political base.”

“The Legislature has rejected this gun range project multiple times,” Nesiba said. “She is using the Future Fund to circumvent the will of the Legislature.” 

Bipartisan reaction

The frustration with the governor cuts across the political aisle.  

“We already killed the shooting range legislation, because they never presented a business plan. Still haven’t,” said Sen. Ryan Maher, R-Isabel. “How many people are going to run this thing? Clean the bathrooms? Pick up trash? Shell casings? They still have not answered any of that.”

Maher sponsored a bill that was adopted during last winter’s legislative session requiring the Governor’s Office to report twice per year to legislators about Future Fund spending. Noem signed that bill on March 14 — the same month, according to her Governor’s Office of Economic Development, that she authorized $13.5 million from the Future Fund for the shooting range. 

Lawmakers contacted this week by South Dakota Searchlight said they have not yet received a Future Fund report as required by the new law.

Maher’s bill arose after Noem faced criticism for other uses of the fund, including $7.5 million she awarded for a workforce recruitment campaign starring herself and $2.5 million for the Governor’s Cup rodeo in Sioux Falls. 

The fund is supported by a tax, described by the state as an “investment fee,” that’s collected from employers in conjunction with payroll taxes for unemployment benefits. In 2023, nearly 30,000 South Dakota employers paid $23 million into the Future Fund. 

The late Gov. George Mickelson convinced lawmakers to create the Future Fund in 1987. State law says the fund must be used “for purposes related to research and economic development for the state.” The fund is held by the Governor’s Office of Economic Development, but unlike other funds managed by the office, the Future Fund is not overseen by a board of citizen appointees.

A controversial range

The shooting range is being built on about 400 acres, roughly 15 miles north of Rapid City and 25 miles southeast of Sturgis. It’s expected to open in the fall of 2025 and will include areas for long-range shooting, clay target shooting and tactical training. State officials say it will host national shooting competitions.

The Department of Game, Fish and Parks initially said in 2021 that the project would cost about $9.9 million. That grew to $12 million in 2022. Then the state paused the project when calls for bids attracted only one. The project price tag had ballooned to about $20 million by the time the state broke ground in December 2023. 

The department said it had received $5.1 million in pledges and donations toward the project as of April.

Some lawmakers opposing previous attempts to fund the range argued state funds should be prioritized for more pressing infrastructure needs. They also said the project should fund itself with private donations, and scale down as needed.

“Why would the state want to compete with privately owned, taxpaying enterprises?” then-Rep. Dean Wink, R-Howes, now a state senator, asked his fellow lawmakers during a House floor debate in 2022. He argued shooting sports opportunities already exist in the area, but programs to address some other public needs do not.

Some landowners near the project, including Matt Kammerer, say it’s unnecessary and will burden local governments with extra infrastructure and public safety costs. 

“There are shooting ranges all around here already,” he said. “Nobody needs this.”  

Shooting sports enthusiast and Second Amendment advocate King Cavalier, of Sturgis, said providing a public place to exercise gun rights is important to ensuring U.S. democracy continues. Shooting events will result in a sales tax boom, he added, making the complex a smart investment for the state.

This South Dakota Searchlight article is republished Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.

Photo:  A rendering of a proposed state shooting range in Meade County. The South Dakota Department of Game, Fish and Parks is leading development of the project. (Courtesy of GF&P).

Related posts

• Rosebud Sioux Tribe gets nearly $8 million from federal program that South Dakota shunned
• Commentary: Flood washes away Governor Kristi Noem’s false veneer of leadership 
•  Is Noem’s Freedom Works Here Campaign ‘as dead as Cricket’ after puppy shooting scandal?
• Commentary: What Noem’s shot heard around the world says about her approach to problems
• ‘Governor’s Cup’ rodeo among recipients of millions from public fund controlled by Noem
• State discussed Freedom Works Here plan with winning firms before opening project for bids
• 66-year-old guy touted in September press release from SD governor’s office might not be best Freedom Works Here recruitment example
• Work, We're On It: Freedom Works Here ads scrutinized, Ohio vendor swiped local idea
• Transparent Positive Pants Governor Noem tried to avoid ethics hearing, seal records
• Positive pants on fire: Democratic opponent Jamie Smith corrects Noem's really bad math
• The first step to recovery is admitting there's a problem; or, Meth, We're On It in South Dakota
• South Dakota News Watch: Wildlife officials express strong stances for and against S.D. pheasant predator bounty program
• Official: South Dakota lacks data to prove trapping program increases pheasant population 
• Governor Kristi Noem's ‘rhetoric’ vs ‘reality’ regarding BLM proposed public lands rule
• South Dakota News Watch: Gov. Kristi Noem pulls support for grocery tax measure over jeopardized tobacco mone\
• Our own Ludlow? Noem partying like 1914 with use of private money to deploy National Guard
• Positive Pants: South DaCOVID Governor Kristi Noem garners the best national headlines
• AP: ‘Slow day:’ South Dakota National Guard emails don’t match Noem border ‘war’ talk
• What the hell was that? Governor Kristi Noem butt of Saturday Night Live cold opening schtick
• South Dakota man wants his image taken out of Governor Noem's latest divisive attack ad
• While South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem looks for a job, Minnesota unemployment rate drops
• Fake state economy news: Noem for Governor digital ad marketed in Iowa, NH, & SC:
• Pants on fire at CPAC: Governor Kristi Noem claims "We kept kids in the classroom
• South Dakota ethics: Will lawmakers resolve Governor Noem's closed-door meeting with daughter violated public trust?
• SD Gov Noem blames Soros' money for pipeline protests; cuts tribes out of anti-protest bills talk 

If you appreciate Bluestem Prairie, you can mail contributions (payable to Sally Jo Sorensen, 600 Maple Street, Summit SD 57266) or use the paypal button in the upper right hand corner of this post.

Or you can contribute via this link to paypal; use email [email protected] as recipient.

I'm on Venmo for those who prefer to use this service: @Sally-Sorensen-6