MN House GOP files lawsuit to force absent DFL members back to Capitol by fining them

Bluestem last left the Minnesota House with Minnesota House operations stuck in the mud, an article republished from the Minnesota Reformer.

Now the Reformer's Michelle Griffith writes up the next chapter.

Minnesota House GOP files lawsuit to force absent DFL members back to Capitol by fining them
by Michelle Griffith

House Republicans on Thursday filed a lawsuit with the Minnesota Supreme Court to compel boycotting Democratic-Farmer-Labor House members back to the Capitol by fining them.

House Democrats have been deliberately staying away from the Capitol for more than two weeks — since Jan. 14 — in an effort to deny Republicans quorum and control of the chamber.

Last week, the Supreme Court ruled that the House needs 68 members for a quorum, leaving Republicans unable to conduct business.

Minnesota Secretary of State Steve Simon has been presiding over the chamber in the absence of a speaker, and every day this week he has declared there’s no quorum and adjourned.

House Republicans have been attempting to propose a motion to get Democrats back to the Capitol, but Simon won’t “recognize” them, meaning the members can’t speak up, according to House rules.

Rep. Harry Niska, R-Ramsey, told reporters that this is beyond Simon’s authority as a presiding officer, so the caucus is asking the Supreme Court to compel Simon to recognize their motion.

Republicans want House members to be fined an amount equal to their salary during the days that they are absent and revoke their per diem privileges for the entire 2025-2026 session.

“Secretary Simon is illegally obstructing our ability to compel absent members as specifically stated in the constitution. Because he refuses to allow a motion on the House floor to hold Democrats accountable, we are taking legal action to make sure it happens,” Niska said in a statement. “Democrats are obstructing House business, and it needs to stop.”

Niska accused Simon, a Democrat, of “playing politics” by denying their chance to offer a motion. House Republicans are using Niska’s law firm to represent them. Unlike the last case in front of the Supreme Court, House Republicans won’t be using the taxpayer’s dime to fund the legal fees, Niska told reporters.

In a statement, a spokesperson for Simon said his office doesn’t comment on pending litigation, but Simon’s position is that “absent a quorum and an organized House of Representatives, the only item in order is adjournment.”

This is the latest development in the power struggle stifling operations in the Minnesota House, which is currently home to 67 Republicans and 66 Democrats.

Negotiations to resolve the power struggle have stalled, and both sides appear to be dug in: House Democrats want written assurance that Republicans will refrain from attempting to unseat one of their members. Republicans want to elect a speaker and control House committees for the next two years — even after a special election for an open seat in the north metro that’s expected to bring the chamber back to a 67-67 tie.

Republican leader Lisa Demuth, R-Cold Spring, told reporters she hasn’t had contact with House Democratic leader Melissa Hortman about continuing negotiations. Hortman in a statement said she was at the Capitol to negotiate on Thursday morning, but Demuth refused to meet with her. Republicans say Hortman never requested a meeting.

At stake is the status of Rep. Brad Tabke, a Shakopee Democrat who won his reelection by 14 votes in a contest marred by 20 missing ballots. A judge ruled in an advisory opinion that Tabke would have won anyway, and a do-over is not needed. The Minnesota Constitution grants the House the power to seat its own members, however, and Democrats fear Republicans will refuse to seat Tabke.

Photo:  Minnesota Secretary of State Steve Simon presided over the House chamber on Jan. 27, 2025, as Democrats continued to boycott the Capitol. Photo by Michelle Griffith/Minnesota Reformer.

This Minnesota Reformer article is republished online under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.

Related posts

• Minnesota House operations stuck in the mud
• MN Supreme Court sides with House DFL, invalidating House GOP’s work for last 2 weeks
• Heckova beginning: Two court decisions upend Minnesota legislative session 
• The ghost of Joe Rolette: DFL walkout at the MN State Legislature isn’t without precedent 
• Minnesota leads again: No other state has ever begun legislative session without clear majorities
• [VIDEO] Session Daily: MNHouse Republicans plan to act as majority, DFL threatens Opening Day absence in power sharing tug-of-war
• DFL Sen. Kari Dziedzic, former MN Senate Majority Leader, dies of cancer at 62
• After Johnson drops notion of appeal, MNHouse 40B special election scheduled for Jan. 28, 2025
• GOP wins MN House majority, for now, after judge rules District 40B DFL candidate ineligible
• Republicans seek Minnesota House majority through two legal challenges
• Dancing in the dark? MNHouse DFL and GOP, tied at 67, locked in a haters’ embrace

If you appreciate Bluestem Prairie, you can mail contributions (payable to Sally Jo Sorensen, 600 Maple Street, Summit SD 57266) or use the paypal button in the upper right hand corner of this post. 

Or you can contribute via this link to paypal; use email [email protected] as recipient.

I'm on Venmo for those who prefer to use this service: @Sally-Sorensen-6